Every time I have arrived at my classroom, Mrs. Rose begins to do testing. She pulls individual students to a separate part of the room where she has them read a book to her. I sit at a table that is next to where Mrs. Rose tests and I listen to many of her students severely struggling with reading. Which makes me wonder, has she taken the time to consider that these students may need more one on one help? Since I began my tutoring I have never seen Mrs. Rose help a student one on one. I see her do individual testing, but whenever a student has a question about their work she quickly tells them she can not help them at that moment. This seems to show me that Mrs. Rose may not understand that some of her students come from homes where their parents will not help them with homework, or encourage them to read, or even show any signs of being interested in their children's schooling. Mrs. Rose needs to be the one who embraces and understands this in order for her students to prosper and grow in both their learning and school. Although I do believe that Mrs. Rose accepts and loves her students for who they are despite whether they are Spanish, African American, Asian, poor or rich, I do not think she fully understands or knows how to embrace and work with their differences.
Jonathon Kozol, writer of "Still Separate, Still Unequal: America's Education Apartheid" talks of how many schools in America are still deeply segregated. By not adapting to the needs of these students who are learning English as a second language or those who have learned English but still struggle with the difficult aspects of it they are segregating their schools. If they fully embraced their students linguistic, ethnic, and sociocultural characteristics than their school would be doing much better than they are. Maybe if more one on one time was spent with Mrs. Rose's students, they would not be struggling with reading.
I could not agree more. It sounds to me that the students will benefit from some one on one time with Mrs. Rose.64% of the students in this school are Hispanic, meaning the primary language spoken at home is Spanish. If Mrs. Rose worked with her students individually and as a class, she can then take notice of her students' progress in reading. I do believe that students should be tested, but only in a fair way. The reason why the students may be struggling is because Mrs. Rose may have not fully prepared them. In addition,I think a teacher must acknowledge her students' sociocultural differences. This will create a better learning experience for the students and for the teacher as well.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with this post. Today's schools have many different language speaking students. Not all students have English as their first language. If Mrs. Rose took extra time to work with the students one on one or in a small group, she would understand that maybe some of the students are not comprehending all the material. This would benefit the students and the teacher because the students would get a better understanding of what they are learning and the teacher would see who is struggling and needs the extra help.
ReplyDeleteHi Chelsea,
ReplyDeleteYou make several observations in this reflection. The first has to do with the segregated nature of your school. The second has to do with the teacher's lack of attention to academic need. In your final paragraph, you argue that the second (lack of attention) leads to the first (segregation). I see it the other way: The segregated space is a result of systemic discrimination; low academic expectations are a reflection of socially constructed racial bias.
Keep thinking on these things,
Dr. August